H. Hamalainen et P. Huttunen, INFERRING THE MINIMUM PH OF STREAMS FROM MACROINVERTEBRATES USING WEIGHTED AVERAGING REGRESSION AND CALIBRATION, Freshwater Biology, 36(3), 1996, pp. 697-709
1. Data on macroinvertebrates and stream chemistry were collected from
sixty-four streams in Finland. Weighted averaging (WA) regression and
calibration models were constructed to infer the minimum pH of stream
s from their invertebrate assemblages. The purpose was to develop an i
nstrument for biological assessment and monitoring of stream acidifica
tion. The WA method was compared with simpler approaches, based on qua
litative invertebrate data and pH tolerance limits, that are widely us
ed. 2. Performance of the two approaches was assessed in terms of corr
elation between the inferred and observed minimum pH within the 'train
ing set', and in terms of root mean squared differences (predicted - o
bserved) (RMSEP) estimated by cross-validation or bootstrap resampling
techniques. The models were further tested using independent data fro
m the literature representative of a wide geographical range. 3. The p
redictive power of the WA models was reasonable (RMSEP 0.40-0.44 pH un
its) in the training set and consistently better than that of the tole
rance limit method. In contrast to the latter, the WA models were able
to infer a minimum pH above 5.5, suggesting they could detect the ear
ly stages of acidification. 4. The WA models performed better than the
tolerance limit method in inferring pH from the independent literatur
e, further demonstrating the superiority and generality of the WA appr
oach. 5. The weighted averaging technique could be an effective and wi
dely applicable tool for contemporary biological monitoring and assess
ment using aquatic invertebrates.