M. Bonaguidimagniaux et al., FOLLOW-UP OF BLOOD-DONORS POSITIVE FOR HC V SEROLOGY AND OF THEIR RECIPIENTS IS INSUFFICIENT, Gastroenterologie clinique et biologique, 20(8-9), 1996, pp. 663-668
Objectives. - Our aim was to study the characteristics of blood donors
with serum anti-HCV antibodies, their medical follow-up based on a qu
estionnaire, and the followup of their recipients who were transfused
before systematic screening of anti-HCV antibodies had begun. Methods.
- From March 1990 to January 1992, 25255 blood donors were tested by
ELISA 1 or ELISA 2 serum tests and confirmed by RIBA 2 test in case of
positivity: 126 (0.5 %) were ELISA positive of whom 40 (0.16 %) were
RIBA 2 positive (n = 18) or indeterminate (n = 22); among the latter,
13 were retested by RIBA 3 which was positive in 2 cases. Thus, the pr
evalence of blood donors with trully positive HCV antibodies testing w
as shown to be between 0.08 and 0.12 %. Among the 126 ELISA positive b
lood donors, 90 had given blood before systematic screening had begun,
involving 232 patients and 50 non nominative products. Results. - In
donors with positive ELISA test, the prevalence of serum ALT activity
> 2N was 17 % if the RIBA test was positive vs 1 % if the test was neg
ative or indeterminate (P = 0.0007). The rate of donors with serum ALT
activity > N before March 1990 was 62.5 % if the RIBA test was positi
ve vs 17.5 % if if was negative (P = 0.01). The follow-up at 2 years o
f 34 out of 40 donors with a positive or indeterminate RIBA test showe
d that 88 % had had at least two serum ALT activity tests, that 12 % h
ad had a serologic test, that 6 % had sought the advice of a specialis
t, and that a liver biopsy was performed in 3 %. The follow-up of reci
pients showed that the response rate of physicians or recipients was 3
7 % (47 % at public hospital and 12 % in private hospital, P < 0.01).
The rate of recipients positive for HCV was 25 %, that is 2 % of the e
ntire group, yielding an estimated 8 % efficiency of the survey. Lack
of screening was due to the lack of responses from physicians or recip
ients in 64 % of cases and to the death of the recipient in 36 % of ca
ses. Conclusion. - HCV seroprevalence among blood donors in France is
closed to that observed in Northern Europe. In this population, there
is a great discrepancy between the ELISA and RIBA tests. During the su
rvey period, the follow-up of HCV positive blood donors seemed to be v
ery insufficient. The screening of their recipients was poorly effecti
ve, thus emphasizing the importance of the systematic and prospective
follow-up of blood donors.