Rk. Misra et Fd. Li, THE EFFECTS OF RADIAL SOIL CONFINEMENT AND PROBE DIAMETER ON PENETROMETER RESISTANCE, Soil & tillage research, 38(1-2), 1996, pp. 59-69
The reliability of penetrometer resistance (P) measurements on forest
sites with the presence of soil structural discontinuity (such as crac
ks, channels, rocks or tree roots) near the penetrometer probe tip was
tested indirectly in this study, The effects of varying radial soil c
onfinement on P for penetrometer probes of different diameters, d (ove
r 2 mm) was used as a measure of the sensitivity of a penetrometer to
the presence of structural discontinuity. Measurements of P were made
on two homogenized forest soils (at constant water contents) compacted
in tubes of various diameters (D) to bulk densities of 0.8 and 1.0 Mg
m(-3). The combinations of D and d were used to obtain radial soil co
nfinement (D/d) in the range of 4-35. Note that smaller values of radi
al confinement here indicate greater restriction to radial soil expans
ion during probe penetration. Although the maximum values of P (i.e. P
') ranged from 0.5 to 5 MPa, no significant effects of radial soil con
finement on P' was evident. In a separate experiment, additional measu
rements of P and P' at a higher bulk density of 1.2 Mg m(-3) showed su
bstantial increase in P' with increased restriction to radial soil exp
ansion for both soils. These results imply that for lightly compacted
soils, reliable measurements of P and P' can be made even if structura
l discontinuity occurs near a penetrometer test site. Results also sho
wed no dependence of P' on probe diameter within the diameter range 2-
8 mm.