M. Davidson et al., COGNITIVE-FUNCTIONING IN LATE-LIFE SCHIZOPHRENIA - A COMPARISON OF ELDERLY SCHIZOPHRENIC-PATIENTS AND PATIENTS WITH ALZHEIMERS-DISEASE, The American journal of psychiatry, 153(10), 1996, pp. 1274-1279
Objective: Previous studies have suggested that geriatric inpatients w
ith chronic schizophrenia manifest profound cognitive impairments. Thi
s study investigated how these cognitive impairments resemble those se
en in degenerative dementing conditions. Method: The neuropsychologica
l battery of the Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer's Di
sease (CERAD), widely used to characterize the cognitive deficits of p
atients with Alzheimer's disease, was used to compare patterns of cogn
itive impairment in 66 triads of subjects consisting of one elderly pa
tient wish Alzheimer's disease, one elderly, institutionalized patient
with chronic schizophrenia, and one elderly, cognitively normal compa
rison subject who were matched on age, gender, and education. For some
analyses, the two groups of patients were divided into subgroups acco
rding to the degree of their cognitive impairment (mild, moderate, or
severe) as determined by their scores on the Mini-Mental State examina
tion. Results: Relative to the comparison subjects, both groups of pat
ients showed cognitive deficits on each of the neuropsychological meas
ures. The schizophrenic patients performed worse than the patients wit
h Alzheimer's disease on rests of naming and constructional praxis but
were less impaired on the test of delayed word recall. These differen
ces were consistent across all levels of severity of globally measured
cognitive impairment. Conclusions: Consistent with earlier findings f
rom postmortem studies, these findings suggest that major differences
exist in the neurobiologic mechanisms responsible for cognitive impair
ment in schizophrenia and Alzheimer's disease. Effects directly attrib
utable to social and environmental differences between these two group
s of patients may also play a role.