Pk. Whelton et al., RECRUITMENT EXPERIENCE IN THE AFRICAN-AMERICAN STUDY OF KIDNEY-DISEASE AND HYPERTENSION (AASK) PILOT-STUDY, Controlled clinical trials, 17(4), 1996, pp. 17-33
Citations number
NO
Categorie Soggetti
Medicine, Research & Experimental","Pharmacology & Pharmacy
Several approaches for recruitment of African American adults with ren
al insufficiency due to hypertension (glomerular filtration rate betwe
en 25 and 70 ml/min/1.73 m(2)) were explored in the Pilot Study for th
e African American Study of Kidney Disease and Hypertension (AASK). Ov
er a period of 42 weeks, prescreening information was obtained on 2880
individuals, of whom 498 (17%) were evaluated at a screening visit. T
wo hundred and twenty-five (8%) had an I-125-iothalamate assessment of
glomerular filtration rate. Ninety-four of 97 participants who met al
l the study eligibility criteria were enrolled in the trial. The most
common reasons for ineligibility during screening were absence of rena
l insufficiency or hypertension, presence of diabetes mellitus, and a
body mass index above the acceptable level. Overall, an average of 31
prescreen contacts and 8 screening visits were conducted for every ran
domization (3.3% yield from prescreening to randomization). Screening
in clinical practice was the most efficient method for recruitment (12
.6% yield from prescreen contact to randomization compared to 1.1% fro
m mass mailing campaigns, 1.3% from mass media campaigns, and 1.7% fro
m referrals by patients with end-stage renal disease). Randomization y
ields increased with progressively higher age ranges (2.4%, 3.3%, and
6.0% prescreen to randomization yields for those aged less than or equ
al to 50, 51-60, and 61-70, respectively). A slight majority (51%) of
the prescreen contacts were women, but 75% of the randomized participa
nts were men. Our results suggest that clinic-based screening is an ef
fective approach for recruitment of African Americans with hypertensio
n and renal insufficiency into clinical trials. They also suggest that
enrollment of African American women in such studies is a special cha
llenge.