A simple analytic model of point-ion electrostatics has been previousl
y proposed [R. Magri, S. -H. Wei, and A. Zunger, phys. Rev. 42, 11 388
(1990)] in which the magnitude of the net charge qi on each atom in a
n ordered or random alloy depends linearly on the number N-i((1)) of u
nlike neighbors in its first coordination shell. Point charges extract
ed from recent large supercell (256-432 atom) local density approximat
ion (LDA) calculations of Cu1-xZnx random alloys now enable an assessm
ent of the physical validity and accuracy of the simple model. We find
that this model accurately describes (i) the trends in q(i) vs N-i((1
)), particularly for fee alloys, (ii) the magnitudes of total electros
tatic energies in random alloys, (iii) the relationships between const
ant-occupation-averaged charges [q(i)] and Coulomb shifts [V-i] (i.e.,
the average over all sites occupied by either A or B atoms) in the ra
ndom alloy, and (iv) the linear relation between the site charge q(i)
and the constant-charge-averaged Coulomb shift <(V)over bar (i)> (i.e.
, the average over all sites with the same charge) for fcc alloys, How
ever, for bcc alloys the fluctuations predicted by the model in the q(
i) vs V-i relation exceed those found in the LDA supercell calculation
s. We find that (a) the fluctuations present in the model have a vanis
hing contribution to the electrostatic energy. (b) Generalizing the mo
del to include a dependence of the charge on the atoms in the first th
ree (two) shells in bcc (fee) - rather than the first shell only - rem
oves the fluctuations, in complete agreement with the LDA data. We als
o demonstrate an efficient way to extract charge transfer parameters o
f the generalized model from LDA calculations on small unit cells.