Wk. Carroll et Rs. Ratner, MASTER FRAMING AND CROSS-MOVEMENT NETWORKING IN CONTEMPORARY SOCIAL-MOVEMENTS, Sociological quarterly, 37(4), 1996, pp. 601-625
This article maps the network of cross-movement activism in Greater Va
ncouver, British Columbia, and explores the relationship between posit
ion in the network and cognitive use of different injustice frames. Th
e study is informed by a neo-Gramscian analysis that views social move
ments as (potential) agencies of counterhegemony. Viewed as a politica
l project of mobilizing broad, diverse opposition to entrenched econom
ic, political, and cultural power, counterhegemony entails a tendentia
l movement toward comprehensive critiques of domination and toward com
prehensive networks of activism. We find that the use of a broadly res
onant master frame-the political-economy account of injustice-is assoc
iated with the practice of cross-movement activism. Activists whose so
cial movement organization (SMO) memberships put them in touch with ac
tivists from other movements tend to frame injustice as materially gro
unded, structural, and susceptible to transformation through concerted
collective action. Moreover, the movements in which political-economy
framing especially predominates-labor, peace, feminism, and the urban
/antipoverty sector-tend not only to supply most of the cross-movement
ties but to be tied to each other as well, suggesting that a politica
l-economy framing of injustice provides a common language in which act
ivists from different movements can communicate and perhaps find commo
n ground.