The MutY protein of Escherichia coil removes mismatched deoxyadenine r
esidues from DNA. In this study, duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containi
ng modified bases are used as model substrates for this enzyme. In con
trast to a recent report [Lu, A.-L., et al. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270,
23582], dA:8-oxo-dG appears to be the preferred natural substrate for
MutY, as evidenced by the specificity constants (k(cat)/K-m) for dA:8
-oxo-dG and dA:dG of 39 600 x 10(-6) and 383 x 10(-6) (min(-1) nM(-1))
, respectively. k(cat) for the duplex containing dA:dG was highest at
lower pH; the rate of cleavage for the duplex containing dA:8-oxo-dG w
as unaffected over a pH range of 5.5-8.0. The presence of an 8-oxo fun
ction in dG increased significantly the rate of removal of dA from all
substrates tested. Replacement of dA by rA reduced the specificity co
nstant of dA:8-oxo-dG to 294 x 10(-6) (min(-1) nM(-1)), whereas replac
ement of dA by 2'-O-methyladenosine virtually abolished enzymatic acti
vity. Modifications of the dG moiety generally were better tolerated t
han those of dA; however, introduction of a methyl ether at the 6 posi
tion of dG produced a noncleavable substrate and replacement of dG by
2'-O-methylguanosine generated a substrate with a low specificity cons
tant. Rates of cleavage of duplexes containing dA:dC and dA:tetrahydro
furan were three orders of magnitude lower than the reference substrat
e. Duplexes containing a carbocyclic analog of dA were not cleaved. A
model is proposed to explain the recognition of DNA substrates by MutY
and the catalytic properties of this enzyme.