EXPLORING THE CONFORMATIONAL BEHAVIOR OF RIGID PORPHYRIN-QUINONE SYSTEMS BY HIGH-TEMPERATURE MD SIMULATIONS AND TEMPERATURE-DEPENDENT H-1-NMR EXPERIMENTS
M. Frank et al., EXPLORING THE CONFORMATIONAL BEHAVIOR OF RIGID PORPHYRIN-QUINONE SYSTEMS BY HIGH-TEMPERATURE MD SIMULATIONS AND TEMPERATURE-DEPENDENT H-1-NMR EXPERIMENTS, JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR MODELING, 2(9), 1996, pp. 383-385
Photoinduced electron transfer reactions play an important role in the
primary step of the biological photosynthesis process. In an attempt
to understand better the mechanism of the charge separation organic do
nor-acceptor molecules containing porphyrins and quinones were designe
d as photosynthesis models. In order to study the structure dependence
of the photoinduced electron transfer twofold and fourfold bridged po
rphyrin-quinone systems with increasing donor-acceptor distance were s
ynthesized (Figure 1) [1, 2, 3]. It was assumed that in these molecule
s the porphyrin and quinone should be linked in a rigid and well-defin
ed orientation. To verify this assumption the conformational behavior
of these systems was studied by high-temperature MD simulations in com
bination with conformational analysis of selected minimized structures
[4, 5]. As an example we describe the dynamical behavior of the quadr
uply bridged porphyrin-quinone with naphthyl groups as aryl spacer (''
naphthyl cage'') (Figure 2) which was investigated by the following ge
nerally used method: The initial structure used for MD simulation was
constructed with the builder modul of INSIGHT II [6]. To stimulate the
dynamics in such rigid molecules as the ''porphyrinquinone cages'' du
ring a simulation time of 1000 ps we had to choose 1000 K as simulatio
n temperature (Figure 3). The CFF91-forcefield [7] was used because it
had been proven to reproduce well the Xray-structures of our porphyri
n-quinone systems [4]. To analyse the dynamic behavior we defined inte
rnal coordinates by which the characteristic motions of the molecule c
an be described efficiently (''characteristical coordinates'') (Figure
4). These ''characteristical coordinates'' were evaluated by statisti
cal methods (frequency plots) (Figure 5). In addition we carried out c
onformational analysis on selected minimized structures with respect t
o the same internal coordinates (Figure 6). In contrast to the basic a
ssumption we found that the ''naphthyl cage'' is not completely rigid.
There is a characteristic dynamic process in the ''naphthyl cage'' (F
igure 7). Nevertheless, the conformational mobility of the fourfold br
idged porphyrin-quinone system is significantly decreased compared to
the twofold bridged porphyrin-quinone system [4]. These calculated res
ults exhibit good agreement with experimental results derived from tem
perature dependent H-1-NMR experiments [3].