Ch. Choi et M. Kertesz, DENSITY-FUNCTIONAL STUDIES OF VIBRATIONAL PROPERTIES OF HCN, H2O, CH2O, CH4 AND C2H4, Journal of physical chemistry, 100(41), 1996, pp. 16530-16537
Small molecules provide a unique testing ground for post-Hartree-Fock
methods because their harmonic force constants and dipole moment deriv
atives are known experimentally. We have compared several density func
tional theory (DFT) methods with various combinations of exchange and
correlation functionals such as BLYP, B3LYP, BP86, B3P86, BPW91, B3PW9
1, BVWN, BVWN5, and BPL in combination with several basis sets for HCH
. Most density functional results provide impressive agreement with th
e experiment for geometries and vibrational frequencies. Methods with
B3 exchange functional consistently overestimate diagonal force consta
nts, while other methods underestimate the CH stretching force constan
t in HCN. However, all calculated dipole moment derivatives of HCN, in
cluding HF, DFT, and QCISD, show less accurate agreement with experime
nt than for vibrational frequencies. The results show a strong depende
ncy on the choice of the basis set and on the form of the density func
tional, On the basis of the extensive basis set and DFT potential depe
ndency studies on HCN, we have applied only the three most promising D
FT's to a calculation of other small molecules in order to generalize
what we have observed. Calculations on H2O CH2O, CH4, and C2H4 molecul
es provide relatively accurate predictions of dipole moment derivative
s. DFT calculations allow unequivocal sign assignments in the determin
ation of atomic polar tensors (APT) of these molecules including a new
assignment of signs of the dipole moment derivatives for C2H4 and con
firming earlier assignments of the H2CO and CP4 of Person et al. These
results further support DFT as a means for obtaining reasonable dipol
e moment derivatives.