A CONTROVERSIAL model of speciation proposes that the development of a
lternative social organizations within populations of group-living ani
mals may drive the inception of reproductive isolation(1-3). The alter
native social behaviours, which are selectively favoured in some socia
l or ecological contexts, may be correlated with distinctive reproduct
ive traits such that significant barriers to interbreeding emerge betw
een coexisting social variants. Evidence for this mode of speciation i
s almost non-existent(3-8), but it provides one of the most compelling
mechanisms for sympatric sepciation(3,8) and could conceivably explai
n many species origins. Here we examine variation in mitochondrial DNA
and two unique nuclear genes to demonstrate that gene flow between sy
mpatric social forms of the fire ant Solenopsis invicta is restricted
to only one of four possible routes. The loss of the other routes resu
lts from incompatibilities in the social systems of the two forms, dem
onstrating the potential for social selection to generate significant
barriers to gene flow and to initiate reproductive isolation.