E. Fabian, INPATIENT PSYCHOTHERAPY OF SCHIZOPHRENIA IN THE DYNAMIC-PSYCHIATRY-HOSPITAL-MENTERSCHWAIGE (WITH A CASE-HISTORY), Dynamische Psychiatrie, 29(3-4), 1996, pp. 227-233
The theoretical concept underlying the clinical work in the Dynamic Ps
ychiatric Hospital Menterschwaige in Munich is that of Ammon's Berlin
School of Dynamic Psychiatry. It has its roots in Freud's psychoanalys
is, in the Ego psychology of Hartmann, Rapaport and Anna Freud and in
the system-theoretical approach (v. Bertalanffy), which Ammon learned
and practiced in the Menninger Foundation in the USA, where he helped
introduce group psychotherapy and milieutherapy in the treatment of ps
ychosis. In 1982, he replaced Freud's libido concept by the principle
of social energy, i.e. the energy of interpersonal contact. Instead of
the dogma of the unintelligible psychosis and of the psychotherapeuti
c pessimism, dynamic psychiatry works with ''the paradigm of intelligi
bility and therapeutic optimism'' (Ammon, Burbiel 1992). In this sense
, healing is only possible for the therapist who believes in healing.
In dynamic psychiatry, man is considered as a group being, shaped by t
he unconscious dynamics of the groups in which he grows up. The pathol
ogical dynamics in early childhood leads to the so-called archaical eg
o diseases, such as the psychoses. Psychotic patients are individuals
who have been abandoned emotionally in their early childhood. Their fa
milies are characterized by reciprocal destructive aggression, rivalry
and jealousy, which impede the contact necessary for healthy developm
ent. Owing to the family's own fear of identity, the child is not allo
wed to develop a constructive aggression. Later his aggression becomes
deficient or destructive, i.e. directed against the surroundings or a
gainst himself. The psychotic patient suffers particularly from an ove
rwhelming anxiety, from which he flees in the world of schizophrenic d
elusions. Thus, the psychotic symptoms fill the ''hole in the ego'' (A
mmon 1972), i.e. the structural deficit in the core of personality. Th
is human-structural understanding of psychosis makes it evident, that
symptomatic treatment cannot result in a durable change. The aim of th
e dynamic psychiatric psychosis therapy is therefore the development o
f the constructive aspects of the personality, the repair of the struc
tural deficit and the development of identity. In the dynamic psychiat
ric hospital, each patient is given a specific therapeutic program. Th
is consists of psychoanalytic individual and group therapy as well as
non-verbal methods (milieu therapy, human-structural dance therapy, mu
sic therapy, art therapy, theatre therapy and horse riding). All thera
peutic levels are integrated in the supervision groups of the staff, i
n the plenary group of the hospital and the case conferences. We will
now describe the inpatient therapy of a psychotic patient: Mr. H., 30
years old, was admitted with the diagnosis of a hebephrenic psychosis,
after longterm neuroleptic medication. He had been the only one of hi
s family ''to fly out of the nest''. For five years he had lived isola
ted and felt persecuted, he had repeatedly demolished his furniture. H
e imagined his father to be ''gas'' and had destroyed the gas oven. In
termittently, he was in a state of beatitude believing himself to be a
n Indian or a bird in a forest. At such times, he would cool his head
for many hours in the toilet. He had made several suicide attempts. M.
H. was the younger of two brothers. He had been expected to be a girl
. As a child, he had suffered from jealousy, since his brother was pre
fered by the father. He described his mother as a tired, depressive wo
man suffering from frequent heart pains. His father drank heavily, was
irritable and aggressive. The climate at home was tense, with quarrel
s and aggression. As positive influences he mentioned both grandmother
s and later his music teachers. While he had felt an outsider in kinde
rgarten and school, he found warmth and interest during the music less
ons. He finished high school and studied music. We can characterize th
e group dynamics of H.'s family as follows: H. grew up in an atmospher
e of emotional abandonment, jealousy and destructive aggression. The d
epressive mother attached the son to herself as a phantasized partner,
causing him guilt feelings and preventing the contact between father
and son, H. found in the hospital a male therapist interested in music
. He experienced the latter as an emotionally open and sympathetic fat
her, at the same time fearing homoerotic submission and dependency. He
acted out these feelings by frequently alternating between symbiotic
fusion and aggressive behaviour. A central aspect of the therapy consi
sted in supporting his creative abilities in the music therapy, art th
erapy and dance therapy. Through these interests he found contact to o
ther patients in the milieu group, whom he had formerly avoided out of
contact anxiety. The psychological tests at admission showed a psycho
tic structure with pronounced destructive self-aggression, manifested
by guilt feelings with sexual contents and by psychosomatic symptoms,
as well as a deficient and destructive anxiety. Thinking was character
ized by compulsion and depressive fixation, further by an extreme conc
retistic disturbance. This made the schizophrenic symptoms understanda
ble, in terms of concretistic-symbolic thinking, against the backgroun
d of his life history: his anger with the emotionally distant father (
imagining the father as gas and destroying the oven), the resistance a
gainst his homosexual anxieties (cooling his head in the toilet), the
extreme abandonment (as an Indian in the forest) and the wish for sepa
ration and freedom (symbolized by the feeling of being a bird flying f
rom the nest). H. acted out his inability to separate from the hospita
l which he experienced as the mother, and from the therapist-father, b
y occasional uncontrolled attacks of rage. He demolished repeatedly th
e toilet and threatened with suicide, thus making a psychiatric interv
ention in a closed ward unavoidable. In order to relieve the symbiotic
link to the therapist, it was decided in the case conference to conti
nue therapy by the splitting method with two additional therapists. In
the art therapy H. could give expression to his symbiotic wishes in c
reative and abstract paintings showing uterus and embryo symbols. The
separation phase of the inpatient therapy was problematic. H. persiste
d in a negativistic attitude for a long time. Now his existential anxi
ety behind the aggression became evident in the transference situation
of the hospital. Finally, the patient felt understood in hi