J. Call et P. Rochat, LIQUID CONSERVATION IN ORANGUTANS (PONGO-PYGMAEUS) AND HUMANS (HOMO-SAPIENS) - INDIVIDUAL-DIFFERENCES AND PERCEPTUAL STRATEGIES, Journal of comparative psychology, 110(3), 1996, pp. 219-232
Four orangutans (1 juvenile, 2 subadults, and 1 adult) and ten 6-8-yea
r-old children were tested in 4 liquid conservation tasks of increasin
g levels of difficulty. Task difficulty depended on the type of transf
ormation (continuous vs. discontinuous quantities) and the relative co
ntrast between the shapes of the containers. Results indicate that ora
ngutans did not display conservation in the strict sense; instead they
showed ''partial'' conservation (intermediate reactions according to
J. Piaget & B. Inhelder, 1941). In contrast, some of the children prov
ided evidence of conservation in all 4 tasks, showing ''true'' or logi
cally necessary conservation in the original sense proposed by J. Piag
et and B. Inhelder (1941). Although orangutans did not show conservati
on in the strict sense, as J. Piaget (1955) and others have generally
agreed it should be defined, orangutans behaved as individual and crea
tive problem solvers, adopting different perceptual strategies dependi
ng on the task.