G. Boyarsky et al., INADEQUACY OF HIGH K+ NIGERICIN FOR CALIBRATING BCECF .1. ESTIMATING STEADY-STATE INTRACELLULAR PH/, American journal of physiology. Cell physiology, 40(4), 1996, pp. 1131-1145
Intracellular pH (pH(i)) was measured in single vascular smooth muscle
(VSM) cells, cultured from rabbit abdominal aorta, using 2',7'-bis(ca
rboxyethyl)-5(6)-carboxyfluorscein (BCECF) on a microscope-based fluor
escence system. Three lines of evidence are presented that using niger
icin along with high external K+ to calibrate intracellular BCECF prod
uces systematic errors in pH(i). 1) The intrinsic buffering power (Pin
t), measured using weak bases (e.g., ammonium), was 2.5 times smaller
than that measured using weak acids (e.g., propionic acid). This discr
epancy became small if pH(i) had really been similar to 0.2 lower than
what was estimated using nigericin-calibrated pH(i) values. 2) Total
cellular buffering power (beta(tot)) in the presence of CO2/HCO3- was
measured and found to be much smaller than could account for the Pint,
together with the contribution of CO2/HCO3- (beta(CO2): assumed to be
an open system buffer). If the true pH(i) values were similar to 0.2-
0.4 lower than our nigericin-calibrated values, then the sum of beta(i
nt) and beta(CO2) equals beta(tot.)3) A null technique was utilized fo
r bracketing steady-state pH(i); estimates of steady-state pH(i) using
this null technique were similar to 0.2 lower than the high K+/nigeri
cin-calibrated estimates. Four other cell types were examined: rat hep
atocytes, rat corticotrophs, human keratinocytes, and rabbit fibroblas
ts. These other cells also displayed discrepancies between null and ni
gericin estimates of steady-state pH(i), as well as differences betwee
n buffering power assessed using weak bases and acids. Finally, one po
tential source for these discrepancies is described: selecting an inap
propriate external K+ to use with nigericin can produce systematic err
ors in pH(i) of similar to 0.1.