Sm. Hall et al., MOOD MANAGEMENT AND NICOTINE GUM IN SMOKING TREATMENT - A THERAPEUTICCONTACT AND PLACEBO-CONTROLLED STUDY, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, 64(5), 1996, pp. 1003-1009
Earlier research indicated that a 10-session mood management (MM) inte
rvention was more effective than a 5-session standard intervention for
smokers with a history of major depressive disorder(MDD). In a 2 X 2
factorial design, the present study compared MM intervention to a cont
act-equivalent health education intervention (HE) and 2 mg to 0 mg of
nicotine gum for smokers with a history of MDD. Participants were 201
smokers, 22% with a history of MDD. Contrary to the earlier findings,
the MM and HE interventions produced similar abstinence rates: 2 mg gu
m was no more effective than placebo. History-positive participants ha
d a greater increase in mood disturbance after the quit attempt. Indep
endent of depression diagnosis, increases in negative mood immediately
after quitting predicted smoking. No treatment differences were found
in trends over time for measures of mood, withdrawal symptoms, pleasa
nt activities and events, self-efficacy, and optimism and pessimism. H
istory-positive smokers may be best treated by interventions providing
additional support and contact, independent of therapeutic content.