A. Mallard, A COLLECTIVE INTERPRETATION OF EXPERIMENT AL RESULTS - COMPARISONS BETWEEN SCIENTIFIC INSTRUMENTS, Sociologie du travail, 38(3), 1996, pp. 293
During an international meeting, a half-dozen European research teams
with the assignment of measuring air pollution were observed. The meet
ing had the objective of comparing the performance of each team's scie
ntific instruments. By following up on meetings and discussions among
researchers, light was shed on the way these scientists created relati
onships among themselves and also between their instruments for measur
ing pollution and ''reality''. These scientists used causal relationsh
ips in a pragmatic, informal way so as to both manage the uncertainty
of measurements and adjust results to conditions at the sites of exper
iments. interactions among scientists help construct a common frame of
reference without the experimental process being overly determined by
the interplay between strictly rational causes or, at the other extre
me, by purely social interests.