This paper estimates that if a cross-section of nonelderly adults swit
ched from comprehensive insurance to a combination of catastrophic ins
urance and a medical savings account (MSA), they would reduce their me
dical spending by between 2% and 8%. The author constructs measures of
the prices individuals pay for medical care under a typical comprehen
sive insurance policy and a particular combination of catastrophic ins
urance and MSA. The difference in prices paid in the two health plans
is combined with price elasticity estimates from the Health Insurance
Experiment to predict changes in spending. Several qualifications to t
he estimate are considered.