1. The West African tree species Albizia zygia, Blighia sapida, Celtis
mildbraedii, Chrysophyllum pruniforme, Cynometra ananta, Guarea cedra
ta, Heritiera utilis, Lophira alata, Mansonia altissima, Milicia excel
sa, Pericopsis elata, Pterygoya macro- Strombosia glaucescens, Termina
lia ivorensis and Triplochiton scleroxylon, which represent different
ecological guilds (pioneers, non-pioneer light-demanders and non-pione
er shade-bearers) and distributions on a rainfall and soil fertility g
radient were tested for their response to differences in irradiance an
d soil fertility. 2. Seedlings were grown for 4 months at a common sit
e on contrasting forest soils from a wet evergreen forest and a moist
semi-deciduous forest and at five irradiances, which mimicked variatio
n in irradiance from single tree falls to cleared land. 3. Pioneer spe
cies responded differently to irradiance by showing higher maximum rel
ative growth rates (>30 mg g(-1) day(-1)) and unit leaf rates (>3.0 g
m(-2) day(-1)) than non-pioneer shade-bearers (<22 mg g(-1) day(-1) an
d <2.1 g m(-2) day(-1), respectively). Particularly at the irradiance
level below 8% of ambient, pioneers also showed higher leaf area ratio
s (>220 cm g(-1)) and specific leaf areas (>400 cm g(-1)) compared to
shade-bearers. Non-pioneer light-demanders showed intermediate respons
es to differences in irradiance. 4. The soil from the wet evergreen fo
rest was more acid (pH less than or equal to 4.87) than the soil from
moist semi-deciduous forest (pH greater than or equal to 6.12). It als
o had lower concentrations of total N and available P, K, Ca and Mn, p
articularly in the topsoil. Seedlings grown in wet evergreen forest so
il showed reduced leaf foliar concentrations of P, Ca and Mg and to a
lesser extent N, compared with those grown in moist semi-deciduous for
est soil, but the response varied between species. Foliar nutrient con
centrations, particularly of P and Mg, were lowest in species naturall
y restricted to wet evergreen forest. 5. The non-pioneer light-demande
r Mansonia altissima and the pioneer T. scleroxylon showed an increase
of 300% and 100%, respectively, in maximum RGR when grown in the more
fertile soil type. In contrast, RGR of the pioneer L. alata was incre
ased by 80% in the less fertile soil. Species-specific differences in
growth response, biomass allocation and foliar nutrient concentration
may explain why some species are restricted to more fertile soils. Sug
gestions for further research are made.