P. Gale, DEVELOPMENTS IN MICROBIOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT MODELS FOR DRINKING-WATER - A SHORT REVIEW, Journal of Applied Bacteriology, 81(4), 1996, pp. 403-410
Microbiological risk assessment (MRA) is the emerging method to predic
t the risks of infection from waterborne pathogens (e.g. rotavirus and
Cryptosporidium parvum) in the drinking water supply. The objectives
of this paper are to review the appropriateness of current models, wit
h emphasis on pathogen exposures through drinking water, and to consid
er the information necessary to further their development. Calculating
pathogen exposures in MRA is currently limited by the fact that patho
gen density data for drinking water supplies are only available for ve
ry large volume samples-much larger than imbibed daily by any consumer
. To develop MRA, information is needed on how pathogens are dispersed
within those large volumes at the resolution of volumes typically con
sumed daily by individuals. Available evidence suggests that micro-org
anisms, including pathogens, are clustered to some degree, even within
small volumes, exposing some drinking water consumers to much higher
doses than others. By assuming pathogens are randomly dispersed, curre
nt models overestimate the risk from the more infectious agents (e.g.
rotaviruses) but underestimate the risk from less infectious pathogens
(e.g. C. parvum). Approaches to modelling pathogen densities in drink
ing water from source water data and treatment removal efficiencies re
quire additional information on the degree to which treatment processe
s (e.g. filtration and coagulation) increase pathogen clustering. The
missing information could be obtained from large-scale pilot plant stu
dies.