A. Falniowski et al., ALLOZYME AND MORPHOLOGY EVOLUTION IN EUROPEAN VIVIPARIDAE (MOLLUSCA, GASTROPODA, ARCHITAENIOGLOSSA), Journal of zoological systematics and evolutionary research, 34(2), 1996, pp. 49-62
The paper describes morphometric and allozymic differences among four
European species of the family Viviparidae: Viviparus contectus (Mille
t, 1813), V. viviparus (Linnaeus; 1758), V. acerosus Bourguignat, 1862
and V. ater (Cristofori et Jan, 1832). Fourteen continuous biometrica
l characters were measured. Incremental discriminant-function analysis
, principal-component analysis, and non-metric multidimensional scalin
g were applied to analysis of the morphometric differences. All the te
chniques confirmed a similar picture: a slight morphometric differenti
ation, with the variability ranges of the species overlapping. On the
other hand, the allozymic differentiation, studied at 12 loci, eight o
f them intra and/or interspecific polymorphic; is much better marked,
the intraspecific Nei's distances among the four V. contectus populati
ons ranging from 0.0014 to 0.0397 mean 0.0166, and interspecific dista
nces ranging from 0.2306 (V. ater-V. acerosus) to 0.9888 (V. contectus
2 and V. viviparus), mean 0.6871. The allele frequencies and genetic
distances (Nei's distance and Cavalli-Sforza and Edwards' chord distan
ce) were used to compute maximum likelihood, additive Fitch-Margoliash
and ultrametric Fitch-Margoliash trees. All the trees presented a sim
ilar pattern, but the maximum-likelihood and additive trees, based on
Cavalli-Sforza and Edwards' distance, seem to reflect the phylogeny be
st. The results are compared with the most parsimonious phylogenies in
ferred for radular, soft-part morphology and anatomy, and opercular da
ta from other papers by us, and the inferred phylogenies are also comp
ared. Although the inferred molecular and morphological phylogenies ar
e little different in topology, the amount of evolution along the corr
esponding branches (measured as the number of changes averaged over al
l reconstructions) is very different, the value of correlation coeffic
ient between the two phylogenies being statistically insignificant. Th
e occurrence of interspecific hybrids is discussed, and the isolation-
by-competition mechanism is postulated. The probable origin of V. vivi
parus from a founder population extremely restricted in number is stre
ssed. The possible history of the group is briefly discussed. The spec
ies is suggested to have originated in an unusual habitat of melt wate
r at a glacier foreland that could have promoted genotypic differentia
tion and sympatric speciation.