H. Hasenauer et al., JOHANNS A-VALUE USED AS COMPETITION INDEX FOR DETERMINING THINNING EFFECTS, Allgemeine Forst- und Jagdzeitung, 167(9-10), 1996, pp. 169-174
The study reports about a thinning experiment in mixed Norway spruce -
Scots pine stands by applying the A-value of JOHANN (1982, 1983 and 1
990), a method for determining competitive trees within selective thin
ning. The method is based on the assumption that the distance between
a subject tree and his competitors can be expressed as the ratio of th
eir breast height diameters weighted by the height of the subject tree
and an assumed A-value, accounting for different thinning intensities
. Competitors are removed when the distance to the subject tree is sho
rter than the distance limit calculated. JOHANN (1982) concluded that
this procedure is a precise measure for calculating the crown release
within thinning experiments and in 1986 the German Association of Fore
st Research Stations incorporated this measure into their official pro
gramm for testing increment responses after thinning treatments. Resul
ts of the study indicate that the A-value can also be used for determi
ning the competition level of single trees within a stand. However an
update of the A-value is suggested because previously assumed A-values
are precise measure for determining the distance to the neighbouring
competitors but do not represent the competition situation after crown
release accurately enough. For Scots pine the crown release resulted
in an increase of the basal area increment only in the treatment follo
wing first 5 year growth period. For the more shade tolerant Norway sp
ruce the effect of thinning was also evident in the second 5 year grow
th period after thinning and increased even slightly.