S. Katoh et al., NEUROLOGIC OUTCOME IN CONSERVATIVELY TREATED PATIENTS WITH INCOMPLETECLOSED TRAUMATIC CERVICAL SPINAL-CORD INJURIES, Spine (Philadelphia, Pa. 1976), 21(20), 1996, pp. 2345-2351
Study design. The neurologic outcome in patients with conservatively m
anaged incomplete closed traumatic cervical spinal cord injuries was e
valuated using the motor scoring system and the Frankel classification
. Objectives. To show that the motor scoring of recovery system combin
ed with functional Frankel grading will make the documentation of fina
l neurologic outcome more accurate for future comparisons of various m
ethods of treatment. Summary of Background Data. The influence of surg
ical and pharmacologic methods of treatment on recovery remains debata
ble. Methods. Sixty-three consecutive patients with incomplete cervica
l injuries who were admitted to the hospital within 2 days after injur
y were included. All patients were treated conservatively with 6 weeks
of bedrest and 6 weeks of mobilization with neck support. Results. Fi
ve patients had neurologic deterioration, and all but one patient reco
vered without surgery. The evaluation of 44 patients who were observed
for more than 12 months showed that the preservation of sharp sensati
on below the level of injury was an indicator of a good prognosis in p
atients whose injuries were classified as Frankel B, and the degree of
recovery of these patients according to the motor score system was co
mparable with that of patients who were classified as Frankel C. All p
atients classified as Frankel C who did not deteriorate recovered in F
rankel grade. All but one of the patients in the Frankel D group recov
ered full motor power. The degrees of motor deficit and recovery did n
ot correlate with the mechanism or the degree of the injury of the spi
nal axis. Conclusion. Conservative treatment remains a good option for
patients with incomplete cervical cord injuries. It is hoped the curr
ent study will be a good basis for comparison of the neurologic outcom
es of different treatment modalities.