Dr. Gerstmann et al., THE PROVE MULTICENTER EARLY HIGH-FREQUENCY OSCILLATORY VENTILATION TRIAL - IMPROVED PULMONARY AND CLINICAL OUTCOME IN RESPIRATORY-DISTRESS SYNDROME, Pediatrics, 98(6), 1996, pp. 1044-1057
Objective. To compare the hospital course and clinical outcome of pret
erm infants with respiratory distress syndrome treated with surfactant
and managed with high-frequency oscillatory ventilation (HFOV) or con
ventional mechanical ventilation (CV) as their primary mode of ventila
tor support. Design. A prospective randomized clinical trial. Setting.
Three community-based level III neonatal intensive care units. Subjec
ts. A total of 125 neonates who were 35 weeks or less estimated gestat
ion requiring intubation and assisted ventilation for respiratory dist
ress syndrome with arterial to alveolar oxygen ratio less than .50. In
terventions. Patients were randomized to continue CV (61 patients) or
be changed to HFOV (64 patients) after exogenous surfactant administra
tion (100 mg/kg). HFOV was used in a strategy to promote lung recruitm
ent and maintain lung volume. protocol respiratory care guidelines wer
e followed; otherwise routine care was provided by each neonatal inten
sive care unit. Measurements and Main Results. No differences were not
ed in demographic features between the two study groups. The study pop
ulation birth weight was 1.51 +/- .47 kg (mean +/- SD), gestational ag
e was 30.9 +/- 2.5 weeks, and study entry age was 2 to 3 hours. Patien
ts randomized to HFOV demonstrated the following significant findings
compared with CV-treated patients: vasopressor support was less intens
ive; surfactant redosing was not as frequent; oxygenation improved mor
e rapidly and remained higher during the first 7 days; fewer infants r
equired prolonged supplemental oxygen or ventilator support; treatment
failure was reduced; more patients survived without chronic lung dise
ase at 30 days; need far continuous supplemental oxygen at discharge w
as less; frequency of necrotizing enterocolitis illness was lower; the
re were fewer abnormal hearing tests; and hospital casts were decrease
d. No differences were seen between the two study groups in the freque
ncy or severity of patent ductus arteriosus, air leak retinopathy of p
rematurity, or intraventricular hemorrhage. Length of hospital stay an
d survival to discharge were similar for HFOV- and CV-treated infants.
Conclusions. When used early with a lung recruitment strategy, HFOV a
fter surfactant replacement resuited in clinical outcomes consistent w
ith a reduction in both acute and chronic lung injury. Benefit was evi
dent for preterm infants both less than or equal to 1 kg and more than
1 kg. In addition, early HFOV treatment may have had a more global ef
fect on patient health throughout the hospitalization, resulting in re
duced morbidity and decreased health tare cost.