The dynamics of capillary pinching of a fluid thread are described by
similarity solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations. Eggers [Phys. Rev
. Lett. 71, 3458 (1993)] recently proposed a single universal similari
ty solution for a viscous thread pinching with an inertial-viscous-cap
illary balance in an inviscid environment. In this paper it is shown t
hat there is actually a countably infinite family of such similarity s
olutions which are each an asymptotic solution to the Navier-Stokes eq
uations. The solutions all have axial scale t'(1/2) and radial scale t
', where t' is the time to pinching. The solution obtained by Eggers a
ppears to be special in that it is selected by the dynamics for most i
nitial conditions by virtue of being less susceptible to finite-amplit
ude instabilities. The analogous problem of a thread pinching in the a
bsence of inertia is also investigated and it is shown that there is a
countably infinite family of similarity solutions with axial scale t'
(beta) and radial scale t', where each solution has a different expone
nt beta. (C) 1996 American Institute of Physics.