Rh. Emerson et al., SURGICAL CLOSING IN PRIMARY TOTAL KNEE ARTHROPLASTIES - FLEXION VERSUS EXTENSION, Clinical orthopaedics and related research, (331), 1996, pp. 74-80
One hundred eight consecutive patients with primary osteoarthritis of
the knee undergoing primary arthroplasty were compared retrospectively
to determine whether surgical closure of the entire wound in flexion
has any effect on range of motion postoperatively over a period of up
to 6 months, The knees of the first 52 patients were surgically dosed
in extension, In the second group of 56 patients, the knees were close
d in 90 degrees to 110 degrees flexion depending on the available moti
on of the joint, Although the patients were not randomized, the groups
were closely matched in age, weight, height, and gender, Preoperative
and postoperative patellar heights were similar in both groups, The p
atients were started on a continuous passive motion device in the reco
very room. At all intervals the flexion measurements were significantl
y better in the flexion closure group. By 6 months the flexion closure
group had surpassed their preoperative measurements, whereas the exte
nsion closure group had not yet achieved this goal. The flexion group
required less home physical therapy than the extension group. Closing
the knee in flexion permits the patients to regain knee motion faster
with less effort, thereby saving money and enhancing patient satisfact
ion.