C. Heine et B. Teschke, SLEEPING-BEAUTY AND THE DIALECTICAL AWAKENING - ON THE POTENTIAL OF DIALECTIC FOR INTERNATIONAL-RELATIONS, Millennium, 25(2), 1996, pp. 399
This discussion piece sets out to introduce Hegelian-Marxist dialectic
, revolving around the wider concept of pr axis, to the wider meta-the
oretical debate in International Relations. A perusal of the peculiar
historical trajectory of IR theory, culminating in the ambiguities of
the current 'post-positivist' debate, establishes the case for the nec
essity of explicating the meta-theoretical foundations upon which scie
ntific statements are predicated, in ol der to allow for meaningful in
ter-paradigm debate and critique to take place. An excursus into the p
hilosophy of science exemplifies the potency, if not superiority of di
alectical thinking over and against various forms of traditional scien
ce, which were gradually forced to modify their positions by drawing o
n dialectical insights. Against this background, the article then obse
rves the almost complete lack of dialectical theory in the discipline
of IR, before it constructively attempts to systematise the core tenet
s of dialectical thinking. It is argued that G.W.F. Hegel's difficult
formal categorical apparatus was given the adequate social content by
Karl Marx allowing for a critical and comprehensive grasp of social an
d international relations.