In this work islandised nickel films have been placed in a symmetric e
nvironment to allow optical excitation of long-range surface modes via
attenuated total reflection. Comparison of modelling theory to the ex
perimental angle-dependent reflectivity data shows that it is not poss
ible to determine the optical permittivity of the thin nickel layer wi
thout knowledge of its thickness, The reflectivity data has a set of d
egenerate fits: the deduced optical permittivities for this degeneracy
describing a circle when plotted as a Cole-Cole plot. This circle is
naively predicted from an analytical three-media theory which ignores
the coupling prism. Moreover, further investigations show that the deg
enerate circle is a general result of fitting reflectivity curves in t
he vicinity of a long range mode.