This paper compares market-generated incentives affecting the design o
f national fiscal policies in a monetary union regime with those corre
sponding to a fixed-exchange-rate regime of limited credibility. The a
nalysis is based on a simple model that yields equilibrium interest ra
tes in the two regimes as a function of the degree of a government's f
inancial and fiscal discipline. It is found that market-based mechanis
ms for fiscal and financial discipline under a monetary union are only
more powerful than under the alternative fixed-exchange regime if gov
ernments are not heavily indebted.