MILD HEAD-INJURY - DIFFERENCES IN PROGNOSIS AMONG PATIENTS WITH A GLASGOW-COMA-SCALE SCORE OF 13 TO 15 AND ANALYSIS OF FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH ABNORMAL CT FINDINGS
Pa. Gomez et al., MILD HEAD-INJURY - DIFFERENCES IN PROGNOSIS AMONG PATIENTS WITH A GLASGOW-COMA-SCALE SCORE OF 13 TO 15 AND ANALYSIS OF FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH ABNORMAL CT FINDINGS, British journal of neurosurgery, 10(5), 1996, pp. 453-460
We performed a retrospective study of 2484 consecutive patients with m
ild head injury (Glasgow Coma Scale score 13-15) who were seen during
a period of 18 months. Of these, 2351 (94.6%) patients scored 15 point
s, 88 (3.5%) scored 14 points and 45 (1.3%) 13 points. A multivariate
analysis showed that advanced age, a lower GCS (13-14) and the presenc
e of skull fracture, and focal signs, significantly increased the inci
dence of abnormal computed tomography (CT) findings. By contrast, the
gender, the mechanism of injury, the occurrence of initial loss of con
sciousness, posttraumatic amnesia and coagulation disorders did not si
gnificantly increase the incidence of abnormal CT findings. Patients w
ith 13-14 GCS had a significantly higher incidence of initial loss of
consciousness, of skull fracture, abnormal CT findings, need for hospi
tal admission, delayed neurological deterioration and need for operati
on than patients with a GCS of 15. Thus, we suggest separating patient
s with a GCS of 13-14 into a different category and recommend performi
ng CT in all those not improving within 4-6 h of injury. Such a policy
makes skull radiography unnecessary in this subgroup. By contrast, sk
ull radiographs may be useful for the triage of patients with a GCS of
15 that represent most of the mild head injury cases; radiographs sho
uld be obtained in patients presenting with initial loss of consciousn
ess or posttraumatic amnesia (27.9% of the total cases) as these two f
indings were associated with a significantly higher incidence of fract
ure. Patients without these two findings (72.1% of the cases) showed a
very low incidence of skull fracture (0.9% in this study) and may be
discharged home with a warning sheet.