K. Lawson et al., ADVERSE PSYCHOLOGICAL EVENTS OCCURRING IN THE FIRST YEAR AFTER PREDICTIVE TESTING FOR HUNTINGTONS-DISEASE, Journal of Medical Genetics, 33(10), 1996, pp. 856-862
A total of 135 participants in the Canadian predictive testing program
me for HD were followed for at least one year in one of four study gro
ups: increased risk (n=37), decreased risk (n=58), uninformative (n=17
), or not tested (n=23). Clinical criteria for an adverse event were a
suicide attempt or formulation of a suicide plan, psychiatric hospita
lisation, depression lasting longer than two months, a marked increase
in substance abuse, and the breakdown of important relationships. Qua
ntitative criteria, as measured by changes on the General Severity Ind
ex of the Symptom Checklist 90-R and the Beck Depression Inventory, we
re also used to identify people who had adverse events. Twenty of the
135 participants (14.8%) had an adverse event. There were no significa
nt differences between those with or without an adverse event with res
pect to age, sex, marital status, education, psychiatric history, gene
ral psychiatric distress, or social supports at baseline. However, evi
dence for depression was associated with an increased frequency of adv
erse events (p<0.04). The adverse events were similar and seen with eq
uivalent frequency in those receiving an increased risk or decreased r
isk and persons at risk who did not receive a modification of risk. Ho
wever, a significant difference was found in the timing of adverse eve
nts for the increased and decreased risk groups (p<0.0002). In the inc
reased risk group all of the adverse events occurred within 10 days af
ter results whereas, in the decreased risk group, all of the adverse e
vents occurred six months or later after reviewing test results. These
results suggest that people entering into predictive testing with som
e evidence of clinical depression warrant special vigilance and also s
uggest that counselling and support should be available for all partic
ipants in predictive testing irrespective of the direction of test res
ults.