Shareholder-initiated proxy proposals on corporate governance issues b
ecame popular in the late 1980s as corporate takeover activity decline
d. We find firms attracting governance proposals have poor prior perfo
rmance, as measured by the market-to-book ratio, operating return, and
sales growth. There is little evidence that operating returns improve
after proposals. The proposals also have negligible effects on compan
y share values and top management turnover. Even proposals that receiv
e a majority of shareholder votes typically do not engender share pric
e increases or discernible changes in firm policies.