Sp. Wiet et al., THE EFFECT OF VASCULAR CURVATURE ON 3-DIMENSIONAL RECONSTRUCTION OF INTRAVASCULAR ULTRASOUND IMAGES, Annals of biomedical engineering, 24(6), 1996, pp. 695-701
Objective: To characterize the effect of vessel curvature on the geome
tric accuracy of conventional three-dimensional reconstruction (3DR) a
lgorithms for intravascular ultrasound image data. Background: A commo
n method of 3DR for intravascular ultrasound image data involves geome
tric reassembly and volumetric interpolation of a spatially related se
quence of tomographic cross sections generated by an ultrasound cathet
er withdrawn at a constant rate through a vascular segment of interest
. The resulting 3DR is displayed as a straight segment, with inherent
vascular curvature neglected. Most vascular structures, however, are n
ot straight but curved to some degree. For this reason, vascular curva
ture may influence the accuracy of computer-generated 3DR. Methods: We
collected image data using three different intravascular ultrasound c
atheters (2.9 Fr, 4.3 Fr, 8.0 Fr) during a constant-rate pullback of 1
mm/sec through tubing of known diameter with imposed radii of curvatu
re ranging from 2 to 10 cm. Image data were also collected from straig
ht tubing. Image data were digitized at 1.0-mm intervals through a len
gth of 25 mm. Two passes through each radius of curvature were perform
ed with each intravascular ultrasound catheter. 3DR lumen volume for e
ach radius of curvature was compared to that theoretically expected fr
om a straight cylindrical segment. Differences between 3DR lumen volum
e of theoretical versus curved (actual) tubes were quantified as absol
ute percentage error and categorized as a function of curvature. Tubin
g deformation error was quantified by quantitative coronary angiograph
y (QCA). Results: Volumetric errors ranged from 1% to 35%, with an inv
erse relationship demonstrated be tween 3DR lumen volume and segmental
radius of curvature. Higher curvatures (r < 6.0 cm) induced greater l
umen volume error when compared to lower curvatures (r > 6.0 cm). This
trend was exhibited for all three catheters and was shown to be indep
endent of tubing deformation artifacts. QCA-determined percentage diam
eter stenosis indicated no deformation error as a function of curvatur
e. Total volumetric error contributed by tubing deformation was estima
ted to be 0.05%. Conclusions: Catheter-dependent geometrical error ari
ses in three-dimensionally reconstructed timed linear pullbacks of int
ravascular ultrasound images due in part to uniplanar vascular curvatu
re. Three-dimensional reconstruction of timed linear pullbacks is robu
st for vessels with low radii of curvature; however, careful interpret
ation of three-dimensional reconstructions from timed linear pullbacks
for higher radii of curvature is warranted. These data suggest that m
ethods of spatially correct three-dimensional reconstruction of intrav
ascular ultrasound images should be considered when more pronounced va
scular curvature is present.