Two screening techniques for identifying point mutations (single-stran
d conformational polymorphism (SSCP) and dideoxyfingerprinting (ddF))
were compared to sequencing to determine their efficiency in detecting
mutations in exons 5-8 of the p53 tumor suppressor gene. Twelve human
glioblastoma cell Lines were studied by each of the three methods, Te
n mutations were identified by sequencing; of these, 10/10 were detect
ed by ddF, while SSCP detected 6/10 true mutations and falsely identif
ied two presumed mutations not confirmed by sequencing. We examined th
e impact of parameters which influence DNA conformation (gel temperatu
re, gel composition, and PCR product size) on the ability of SSCP and
ddF to detect mutations. The sensitivity of SSCP varied with both gel
temperature and the size of the PCR product; in contrast, ddF was not
influenced by either gel temperature or product length (up to 460 nucl
eotides), We conclude that the increased sensitivity of ddF, together
with its greater ease of application due to the lack of need for optim
ization, provides significant advantages over SSCP in screening DNA se
quences for the presence of point mutations, Our results also suggest
that the incidence of p53 mutations may be underestimated in studies o
f human cancers which utilize SSCP as the method of mutational screeni
ng.