Jj. Fanara et al., THE EVOLUTIONARY HISTORY OF DROSOPHILA-BUZZATII .33. ARE OPUNTIA HOSTS A SELECTIVE FACTOR FOR THE INVERSION POLYMORPHISM, Heredity, 77, 1996, pp. 500-508
Previous work has shown fitness differences among chromosomal arrangem
ents by means of selection component analysis in two Drosophila buzzat
ii natural populations, one of which is native to Argentina and the ot
her a colonized population from Carboneras, Spain. Founder effects or
niche shifts were proposed to explain the differences observed in the
pattern of pleiotropic effects of inversions on fitness components. In
this paper, we address the possible role of niche shifts by determini
ng whether differential attraction to, oviposition on, or utilization
of the rotting cladodes of two different Opuntia species (O. quimilo a
nd O. ficus-indica) occurred among individuals carrying different seco
nd chromosome karyotypes in a natural Argentinian population. Through
the analysis of more than 2500 individuals comprising five different l
ife cycle stages associated with the necroses of these two cactus spec
ies, we found that the distributions of inversion frequencies in sampl
es of adult flies, third instar larvae and emerging adults collected o
n both Opuntia species were not significantly different. Likewise, no
evidence of differential oviposition was observed. These findings sugg
est that niche shifts cannot, solely, account for the changes observed
in the Carboneras population. In addition, the selection component an
alysis did not reveal any significant relationship between chromosomal
arrangements and the fitness components tested. These results suggest
either that fitness differences might be too small to be detected or
that the assumptions of the model concerning the mode of selection may
not be tenable in the studied population.