We show that the dynamics of the scalar field phi(x)=''G(-1)(x)'' in B
rans-Dicke theories of gravity makes the surface area of the black hol
e horizon oscillatory during its dynamical evolution. It explicitly ex
plains why the area theorem does not hold in Brans-Dicke theory. Howev
er, we show that there exists a certain nondecreasing quantity defined
on the event horizon which is proportional to the black hole entropy
for the case of stationary solutions in Brans-Dicke theory. Some numer
ical simulations are demonstrated for Oppenheimer-Snyder collapse in B
rans-Dicke theory.