Fp. Howe et al., DIRECT AND INDIRECT EFFECTS OF INSECTICIDE APPLICATIONS ON GROWTH ANDSURVIVAL OF NESTLING PASSERINES, Ecological applications, 6(4), 1996, pp. 1314-1324
We conducted an experiment in 1989 and 1990 to determine the effects o
f malathion ultra-low volume (ULV) aerial spray on reproduction of pas
serine birds in shrub-steppe habitat of southern Idaho. The experiment
consisted of reducing the insect food base with malathion, a broad-sp
ectrum insecticide, while monitoring nestling growth variables and dai
ly nest survivorship. Relative arthropod abundance and biomass were re
duced on the treatment plot in 1989 and 1990 (F. P. Howe et al., unpub
lished manuscript). Wing and tarsus lengths of nestling Sage Thrashers
(Oreoscoptes montanus) were shorter on the treatment than on the cont
rol plot after malathion application in 1989 but not in 1990. Nestling
Brewer's Sparrow (Spizella breweri) wing length and mass were lower o
n the treatment plot in 1990 but not in 1989. Primary length and foot
length were unaffected for either species in either year. Multivariate
ANOVA indicated that nestling Brewer's Sparrow ''size'' (a combinatio
n of five growth variables) was smaller on the treatment than on the c
ontrol site after the 1990 treatment, but similar between sites after
the 1989 malathion application. Sage Thrasher nestling ''size'' was sm
aller on the posttreatment malathion plot in 1989, but similar between
plots in 1990. The percentage of eggs hatched and percentage of nestl
ings hedged were unaffected for either species. No differences were de
tected in Mayfield estimates of nest survivorship for either species i
n either year, The mean number of Sage Thrashers fledged per nest atte
mpt was Lower on the treatment than on the control plot in 1989, but n
ot in 1990. The mean number of Brew er's Sparrows fledged per nest att
empt was not affected on the treatment plot. No adult mortality for ei
ther species was observed, and nestling mortalities could not be attri
buted to malathion. Thus, few differences were detected in nestling gr
owth variables and nest survivorship between the control and treatment
plots, and these differences were not consistent across years. Under
the conditions of this study, malathion had no observable direct effec
ts, and only marginal indirect effects, through food-base reduction, o
n Brewer's Sparrow and Sage Thrasher nestling growth and survival.