Sr. Gislason et al., CHEMICAL-WEATHERING OF BASALT IN SOUTHWEST ICELAND - EFFECTS OF RUNOFF, AGE OF ROCKS AND VEGETATIVE GLACIAL COVER/, American journal of science, 296(8), 1996, pp. 837-907
Compared to the global average, the chemical weathering rates of basal
t in southwest Iceland are high and rather variable. This can be attri
buted to soluble rock type (buasalt) and mechanical weathering, variat
ion in runoff and age of rocks, and variable vegetative/glacial cover.
The average temperature of the catchments in this study is near const
ant, 5 degrees C. Chemical weathering of the basalt is incongruent. So
me of the primary minerals do not dissolve, and secondary minerals for
m, resulting In the fact that fluxes of all elements increase with run
off, and there is an enormous variation in the relative mobility of el
ements in the basalt during weathering. The relative mobility, in decr
easing order, is: S > F > Na > K >>> Ca > Si > Mg > P > Sr much greate
r than Mn > Al > Ti > Fe. Relative to Na, close to 90 percent of Mg an
d Ca in the original rocks is left behind at the weathering site. The
runoff dependence of fluxes and the variation in relative mobility is
less in old rocks than in young ones. In old rocks the number of satur
ated minerals with respect to soil solutions has decreased because of
lesser amount of soluble basaltic glass and an increased vegetative co
ver on old rocks. The saturation state of basaltic minerals is the mos
t important variable for the dissolution and precipitation rate of min
erals during weathering in southwest Iceland and is dictated by the pH
of the weathering solutions. The overall rate of chemical denudation
rate in southwest Iceland is independent of vegetative cover. However,
fluxes of Ca, Mg, and Sr Increase with increasing vegetative cover at
constant runoff, whereas fluxes of Na and K decrease. With a continuo
us vegetative cover the pH of the soil solutions tends to be low (<7),
and glass, olivine, pyroxene, and plagioclase are unstable, but the s
olutions are decreasingly saturated or more undersaturated with respec
t to zeolites and smectite, thus increasing the relative mobility and
fluxes of Ca, Mg, and Sr. Since the weathering of Ca-Mg silicate rocks
is the principal process by which CO2 is removed from the atmosphere
on a geological time scale (Berner, 1992), the spread of vascular plan
ts on the continents during the mid-Paleozoic may have resulted in a d
rop in CO2, not necessarily because of greatly enhanced bulk chemical
weathering, as suggested by Trendall (1966) and Berner (1993), but rat
her due to the enhanced relative mobility and fluxes of Ca and Mg. Gla
cial cover slows down the overall chemical denudation rates in southwe
st Iceland. It increases the probability of high pH weathering solutio
ns by excluding direct and indirect routes for the CO2 from the atmosp
here to the weathering site and by continuously exposing fresh rocks t
o the incoming solutions. A high pH (8-10) makes the primary Ca silica
tes stable and the Mg silicates stable or less unstable, and the high
pH increases the probability of deposition of zeolites and smectites.
Thus, the relative mobility and fluxes of Ca and Mg slow down during g
lacial cover and therefore retard the permanent long-term consumption
of atmospheric CO2. This process supports the theory of a negative fee
dback mechanism for the long-term stabilization of the Earth's surface
temperature (Walker, Hays, and Kasting, 1981). Transient consumption
of atmospheric CO2 by chemical weathering in Iceland is greater than C
O2 degassing from the Icelandic mantle plume. However, long-term consu
mption by weathering of Ca-Mg silicates and precipitation of Ca-Mg car
bonates in the ocean is smaller than the CO2 degassing. The relative m
obility of the least mobile elements during weathering in southwest Ic
eland is similar to that observed elsewhere in the world under remarka
bly variable climatic conditions. Thus we agree with Nesbitt and Wilso
n (1992) and Taylor and others (1992) that laterites and bauxites are
not necessarily representative of a tropical climate, but rather the r
atio of mechanical versus chemical denudation rates. Icelandic precipi
tation shows a normal distribution around a mean pH of 5.4. Na/Cl, K/C
l, Mg/Cl, and Sr/Cl ratios in the precipitation are close to oceanic r
atios, indicating that they are solely of marine origin. The concentra
tions of Ca, SO4, NO3, and NH4 are higher than predicted by an unfract
ionated marine contribution. The pH of spring-fed rivers In southwest
Iceland is high, and they are relatively poor in total dissolved inorg
anic carbon, calcium, and magnesium. The pH of other rivers ranges fro
m 7.15 to 7.94, which is typical for waters with access to atmospheric
CO2 during or after water-rock interaction. The water in the main cha
nnels of the rivers has enough time for significant heat exchange with
its surroundings and significant gas exchange with the atmosphere, bu
t the water-rock interactions are insignificant. The airborne dissolve
d or soluble solids contribution to the total dissolved solids in rive
rs in southwest Iceland (only carbon dissolved in rain is considered)
ranges from 14 to 38 percent for those catchment areas closest to the
coast. Most of the airborne contribution is of marine source and the a
irborne contribution is, in descending order; Cl, NO3, and NH4 (approx
imate to 100 percent) > Sr (44 percent) greater than or equal to SO4 (
42 percent) > Na (33 percent) > Mg (23 percent) greater than or equal
to K (21 percent) > Ca, PO4 (13 percent) much greater than SiO2, F, Al
, Fe, Mn, Ti (0 percent). The dissolved carbon in the rivers is primar
ily, directly, or indirectly derived from the atmosphere. The average
total dissolved inorganic N content of Icelandic precipitation is 124
mu g/l N, but the discharge weighted average of the total inorganic N
concentration of Icelandic rivers is 62 mu g/l N. Thus there is a nitr
ogen sink in Icelandic catchment areas, caused by primary production o
f progressive vegetation and biota.