European strains of Armillaria cepistipes were reported to be interfer
tile with strains from three American Armillaria species known as Nort
h American Biological Species (NABS) V (A. sinapina), NABS X and NABS
XI. Such interfertility between species raises some doubts about using
different Latin binomials for species capable of mating. This interfe
rtility was reinvestigated by mating 24 haploid isolates of European A
. cepistipes with 23 isolates of A. sinapina from North America and As
ia. Individual pairings were independently performed at least once at
Universite Laval, Canada and at INRA Clermont-Ferrand, France. From th
e 420 interspecific pairings performed at Laval, two were positive and
seven were ambiguous for a total of 2.1% of all the pairings. From th
e 506 pairings made at Clermont-Ferrand, 10 were positive and 24 were
ambiguous for a total of 6.7%. The differences in the pairing results
may be explained by incubation temperatures, and the different types a
nd concentrations of malt extract used at each laboratory. The low lev
els of interfertility found between A. cepistipes and A. sinapina may
result from the absence of genetic barriers that are usually present b
etween sympatric species. This low level of interfertility reflects di
fferences in morphology, distribution, and habitat for these two speci
es of Armillaria and this supports the retention of different species
denominations.