Coal balls are formed from the precipitation of carbonate minerals, pr
edominantly calcite, from water during or immediately post-peat format
ion. Previous petrological studies suggest permineralization occurred
at various stages during the peatification process by precipitation fr
om a mixture of marine and meteoric freshwater. The geochemical studie
s reported here aimed to test previous theories of coal ball formation
. Coal balls studied here are from Upper Carboniferous and Carbonifero
us/Permian coal seams in Britain, United States of America, Belgium an
d China. Stable carbon isotopic values of calcites range from delta(13
)C of -5 to -35 parts per thousand indicating highly variable contribu
tion of decayed organic matter to the carbonate cement. Oxygen isotopi
c values of delta(18)O range from -3 to -15 parts per thousand suggest
both marine and meteoric freshwater sources. The range, in the Britis
h coal balls in particular, with delta(13)C ranging from -7 to -25 par
ts per thousand indicates the complexity of carbonate generation. Isot
opic data support at least four theories of carbonate coal ball format
ion. This makes their absence from post-Permian coals the more puzzlin
g and it is suggested that the overall structure of the peat may play
a role.