DIVERSITY OF VIBRIO-ANGUILLARUM ISOLATES FROM DIFFERENT GEOGRAPHICAL AND BIOLOGICAL HABITATS, DETERMINED BY THE USE OF A COMBINATION OF 8 DIFFERENT TYPING METHODS
I. Kuhn et al., DIVERSITY OF VIBRIO-ANGUILLARUM ISOLATES FROM DIFFERENT GEOGRAPHICAL AND BIOLOGICAL HABITATS, DETERMINED BY THE USE OF A COMBINATION OF 8 DIFFERENT TYPING METHODS, Systematic and applied microbiology, 19(3), 1996, pp. 442-450
In the present investigation we have studied 260 presumed Vibrio angui
llarum isolates from a wide range of habitats, using a combination of
eight different typing methods. The aims of the study were to investig
ate the diversity of V. anguillarum, as indicated by the use of combin
ed typing, and to determine if strains with identical or similar chara
cteristics were present in certain geographical locations, or in certa
in fish species. We also present a simple numerical method to analyse
data obtained from combined typing. Two hundred and sixty isolates nam
ed as V. anguillarum from various fish species, rotifers, Artemia, wat
er and sediment were subjected to the following eight assays: Species
identification using ribotyping and the BIOLOG GN plates, subtyping us
ing determination of outer membrane profiles, plasmid typing, serotypi
ng, determination of lipopolysaccharide profiles and biotyping with AP
I 20E, and biochemical fingerprinting with the PhenePlate system. The
diversity among all isolates, calculated as Simpson's diversity index
(Di), varied between 0.19 (ribotyping), i.e. most isolates belonged to
the same type, and 0.98 (PhP), i.e. most isolates different. Upon com
bination of all methods, where a difference between two strains in at
least two methods was regarded as significant, a diversity of 0.92 was
obtained. Isolates collected from fish showed lower diversity (Di = 0
.89) than those collected from other sources (environment, rotifers, A
rtemia) (Di = 0.98). The lowest diversities were found among isolates
collected from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), salmon (Salmo sola
r) and turbot (Scophthalmus maximus). Isolates from close geographical
locations were also less diverse than isolates obtained from more dis
tant locations. We conclude that the diversity of V. anguillarum is hi
gh, as shown by the combined typing methods. However, it seems that st
rains with specific characteristics are associated with certain geogra
phic areas, and also with certain fish species. This could only be det
ected by applying a combination of several typing methods. Our results
emphasise the need to use several different typing methods for studie
s of bacterial diversity.