S. Porter, WITHOUT CONSCIENCE OR WITHOUT ACTIVE CONSCIENCE - THE ETIOLOGY OF PSYCHOPATHY REVISITED, Aggression and violent behaviour, 1(2), 1996, pp. 179-189
Despite an impressive body of research spanning seven decades, the cau
ses of psychopathy and psychopathic violence remain enigmatic for ment
al health professionals and society as a whole. A keystone of the diso
rder is the absence of normal human emotional experience. In recent ye
ars, a predominant view has been that a genetic predisposition is esse
ntial to its formation while environmental factors determine the cours
e of the disorder The present paper proposes an alternate, less common
pathway to psychopathy in which environmental factors are critical ('
'secondary psychopathy''). Clinical and empirical evidence is reviewed
supporting the hypothesis that negative childhood experiences can pro
foundly affect emotional functioning in adulthood Specifically, certai
n individuals who are severely traumatized or disillusioned by loved o
nes might over time learn to ''turn off'' their emotions as an effecti
ve coping mechanism, later emerging as psychopathic personality disord
er It is argued that, with continued validation of the hypothesis, sec
ondary psychopathy should be considered a distinctive dissociative dis
order based on this detachment of emotion and cognition/behavior.