K. Spitze et Td. Sadler, EVOLUTION OF A GENERALIST GENOTYPE - MULTIVARIATE-ANALYSIS OF THE ADAPTIVENESS OF PHENOTYPIC PLASTICITY, The American naturalist, 148, 1996, pp. 108-123
Phenotypic plasticity, whereby a single genotype produces alternative
phenotypes in alternative environments, is often cited as a characteri
stic of generalists: the alternative phenotypes allow the species to e
xploit a broader range of environmental conditions. However, plasticit
y may be adaptive or may simply result from developmental instability,
Most recent work on the adaptiveness of plasticity has focused on ana
lyses of single traits, whereas the alternative phenotypes are likely
to involve alteration of a suite of characters. Multivariate analysis
would allow separation of direct adaptive plasticity from what we term
indirect adaptive plasticity. Predator-prey inducible defense systems
, such as the interaction between larval Chaoborus americanus (an aqua
tic dipteran ambush predator) and Daphnia pulex (a freshwater crustace
an) provide excellent opportunities to evaluate the adaptiveness of pl
asticity, This study was conducted to separate direct from indirect ad
aptive induced change in Daphnia for morphological characters with res
pect to the agent that causes the induced change: the presence of Chao
borus. Of the eight characters assayed, four were found to independent
ly contribute to the enhanced fitness exhibited by the induced morph.
The differences between the interpretation of the data based on univar
iate and multivariate analyses were marked, This underscores the impor
tance of assessing tile adaptiveness of plasticity in a multivariate c
ontext.