The comment by R. L. Dowden does not properly represent the results pr
esented in our recent paper [Inan ct al., 1995] and attempts to premat
urely classify the VLF events reported in our papers as being produced
by elves. There is no experimental evidence that the VLF events repor
ted in our papers are necessarily associated with the optical phenomen
a of elves. In our recent paper [Inan et al., 1996a] we provide a phys
ically based mechanism which accounts for the forward scatter property
of the VLF events observed in our data.