ESTIMATION OF SKIN PRICK TEST REACTIONS WITH A SCANNING PROGRAM

Citation
H. Pijnenborg et al., ESTIMATION OF SKIN PRICK TEST REACTIONS WITH A SCANNING PROGRAM, Allergy, 51(11), 1996, pp. 782-788
Citations number
16
Categorie Soggetti
Allergy,Immunology
Journal title
ISSN journal
01054538
Volume
51
Issue
11
Year of publication
1996
Pages
782 - 788
Database
ISI
SICI code
0105-4538(1996)51:11<782:EOSPTR>2.0.ZU;2-V
Abstract
We evaluated a new method of computer-based scanning of skin prick tes t wheal areas. To test the calibration of the program, we scanned five constructed circles of exactly defined areas between 5 and 255 mm(2). One of these circles was scanned in different degrees of contrast (mo des), the middle mode being used in the other experiments. We also inv estigated the inter- and intraoperator variation, Finally, results obt ained by measuring diameters of wheals and by the new method of area d etermination were compared for 82 histamine and 75 egg wheals. The are as found agreed well with the real areas (P<0.01) (mean 97.4-100.8%), except for the smallest wheal (5 mm(2)) (NS). Areas obtained in the '' middle position'' closely resembled the real area. The intraoperator c oefficient of variation (c.v.) was 1.4% (0.3-4.3), the day-to-day c.v. was 1.9% (0.2-5.3), and the interoperator c.v. was 2.3% (0.7-5.7), wi th a higher c.v. for small areas. Histamine and egg wheals were signif icantly larger with the diameter method (126% and 129%, respectively) than with the area method. The difference between the methods was most pronounced for small wheal areas. The c.v. of the scanning method was significantly lower than that of the diameter method. The new program is precise and is recommended for registration of skin test reactions in scientific trials. Although the scanner works well and has high pr ecision, the major problem in skin testing seems still to be the repro ducibility of the skin test technique employed.