Mj. Glendining et al., THE EFFECTS OF LONG-TERM APPLICATIONS OF INORGANIC NITROGEN-FERTILIZER ON SOIL-NITROGEN IN THE BROADBALK WHEAT EXPERIMENT, Journal of Agricultural Science, 127, 1996, pp. 347-363
The Broadbalk Wheat Experiment at Rothamsted (UK) includes plots given
the same annual applications of inorganic nitrogen (N) fertilizer eac
h year since 1852 (48, 96 and 144 kg N/ha, termed N-1, N-2 and N-3 res
pectively). These very long-term N treatments have increased total soi
l N content, relative to the plot never receiving fertilizer N (N-0),
due to the greater return of organic N to the soil in roots, root exud
ates, stubble, etc (the straw is not incorporated). The application of
144 kg N/ha for 135 years has increased total soil N content by 21%,
or 570 kg/ha (0-23 cm). Other plots given smaller applications of N fo
r the same time show smaller increases; these differences were establi
shed within 30 years. Increases in total soil N content have been dete
cted after 20 years in the plot given 192 kg N/ha since 1968 (N-4). Th
ere was a proportionally greater increase in N mineralization. Crop up
take of mineralized N was typically 12-30 kg N/ha greater from the N-3
and N-4 treatments than the uptake of c. 30 kg N/ha from the N-0 trea
tment. Results from laboratory incubations show the importance of rece
ntly added residues (roots, stubble, etc) on N mineralization. In shor
t-term (2-3 week) incubations, with soil sampled at harvest, N mineral
ization was up to 60% greater from the N-3 treatment than from N-0. In
long-term incubations, or in soil without recently added residues, di
fferences between long-term fertilizer treatments were much less marke
d. Inputs of organic N to the soil from weeds (principally Equisetum a
rvense L.) to the N-0-N-2 plots over the last few years may have parti
ally obscured any underlying differences in mineralization. The long-t
erm fertilizer treatments appeared to have had no effect on soil micro
bial biomass N or carbon (C) content, but have increased the specific
mineralization rate of the biomass (defined as N mineralized per unit
of biomass). Greater N mineralization will also increase losses of N f
rom the system, via leaching and gaseous emissions. In December 1988 t
he N-3 and N-4 plots contained respectively 14 and 23 kg/ha more inorg
anic N in the profile (0-100 cm) than the N-0 plot, due to greater N m
ineralization. These small differences are important as it only requir
es 23 kg N/ha to be leached from Broadbalk to increase the nitrate con
centration of percolating water above the 1980 EC Drinking Water Quali
ty Directive limit of 11.3 mg N/I. The use of fertilizer N has increas
ed N mineralization due to the build-up of soil organic N. In addition
, much of the organic N in Broadbalk topsoil is now derived from ferti
lizer N. A computer model of N mineralization on Broadbalk estimated t
hat after applying 144 kg N/ha for 140 years, up to half of the N mine
ralized each year was originally derived from fertilizer N. In the sho
rt-term, the amount of fertilizer N applied usually has little direct
effect on losses of N over winter. In most years little fertilizer-der
ived N remains in Broadbalk soil in inorganic form at harvest from app
lications of up to 192 kg N/ha. However, in two very dry years (1989 a
nd 1990) large inorganic N residues remained at harvest where 144 and
192 kg N/ha had been applied, even though the crop continued to respon
d to fertilizer N, up to at least 240 kg N/ha.