Numerical models can show large errors in the modelling of flow around
tall topography. We present a weakly nonlinear analytical solution of
barotropic oscillatory flow over a tall axisymmetric seamount and com
pare the results to a numerical tidal model. The comparison is formula
ted for a flat topped seamount with parabolic sides and for a standing
wave boundary condition in order to make the problem analytically tra
ctable and to reduce it to a series of ordinary differential equations
. The comparison shows reasonable agreement within the confines of the
analytical formulation confirming that the numerical model can exploi
t tall topography. Comparisons to a Gaussian seamount and Kelvin wave
forcing illustrate the generality of the results. The analytical formu
lation produces an equation relating relative errors in the comparison
to discontinuities in topographical slope; the numerical model should
have smaller errors over smoother topography. Residual velocities are
found to be proportional to the aspect ratio of the topography.