S. Clayton et Ma. Aizen, EFFECTS OF POLLINIA REMOVAL AND INSERTION ON FLOWER LONGEVITY IN CHLORAEA-ALPINA (ORCHIDACEAE), Evolutionary ecology, 10(6), 1996, pp. 653-660
Although it is known that stigmatic pollen deposition may trigger earl
y flower senescence, the existence of a similar plastic response of fl
ower lifespan to pollen removal has been much less studied. Here we re
port on a factorial, manipulative experiment in which all 2 x 2 flower
combinations of pollinia removal and stigmatic pollinia insertion wer
e performed in inflorescences of the Patagonian ground orchid Chloraea
alpina. This experiment was conducted in the laboratory, in a populat
ion of cut inflorescences and in the field. We hypothesized that if ex
pected fitness gains, through both the male and female functions, were
weighed against the costs of flower maintenance, then early flower se
nescence should be triggered by either pollinia removal or insertion.
The shortest flower lifespan would be expected in flowers where both p
rocesses occurred. Results showed that flower longevity was very stron
gly affected by pollinia insertion, reducing the flower lifespan by ap
proximately 60%. The response of pollinia removal was much weaker. A s
ignificant reduction in flower longevity caused by pollinia removal wa
s only detected in unpollinated flowers (i.e. no pollinia inserted). W
ithin the racemose inflorescences, flowers in basal positions lived lo
nger than flowers in terminal ones, which might be evidence of the imp
ortance of resource availability in determining maximum flower longevi
ty. The observed responses of flower lifespan plasticity to pollinia m
anipulation only partially supported our expectations based on fitness
benefit-cost relationships. Other factors that might explain these di
screpancies are the different fitness gains that may indeed accrue to
the processes of pollinia removal and insertion as they occur in natur
e, donor manipulation of the recipient flower lifespan associated with
the evolution of pollen clustering into pollinia and physiological co
nstraints in terms of the extent to which flower longevity may respond
to pollen removal.