Jm. Bullock et al., PLANT DEMOGRAPHIC RESPONSES TO ENVIRONMENTAL VARIATION - DISTINGUISHING BETWEEN EFFECTS ON AGE STRUCTURE AND EFFECTS ON AGE-SPECIFIC VITAL-RATES, Journal of Ecology, 84(5), 1996, pp. 733-743
1 The vital rates (e.g. fecundity, growth or mortality) of a plant pop
ulation can each be expressed as the scalar product of the vectors n(t
), representing the age structure, and m(t), representing the age-spec
ific values of the vital rate. We hypothesize that environmental chang
e can affect a vital rate of a plant population through one of two mec
hanisms: by changing the population age structure (hypothesis 1), or b
y altering the age-dependent vital rates (hypothesis 2). 2 We determin
ed which of these hypotheses best explained the effects of different g
razing treatments, applied in a field experiment, on the population ti
ller production of two pasture grasses, Agrostis stolonifera and Loliu
m perenne. 3 Monthly censuses of mean per capita tiller production wer
e carried out for two years and grazing effects were detected in a num
ber of censuses. 4 Tiller production by individual tillers was age-dep
endent and increased linearly with tiller age. 5 Grazing treatments si
gnificantly changed both the age structures (n(t)) of the tiller popul
ations in most censuses and the regression of tiller production on age
(m(t)) in a number of censuses. 6 Treatment effects on population til
ler production predicted according to hypothesis 1 were calculated usi
ng measured values for n(t) specific to each grazing treatment and the
mean values for m(t) over all treatments. Conversely, effects predict
ed according to hypothesis 2 were calculated using mean values for n(t
) and values for m(t) specific to each grazing treatment. 7 The grazin
g effects on tiller production predicted by hypothesis 2 fitted the fi
eld data significantly for both species in all grazing treatments wher
eas hypothesis 1 never gave a significant fit. Therefore, grazing effe
cts on population tiller production arose solely through changes in th
e age-specific values for tillering and never through effects on the p
opulation age structures. 8 We discuss the reasons for these results a
nd consider the mechanisms of the responses to grazing. We also assess
the use of these hypotheses in determining the ecological processes g
overning plant demographic change.