Ce. Kindell et al., THE EFFECTS OF SURROUNDING VEGETATION AND TRANSPLANT AGE ON THE DETECTION OF LOCAL ADAPTATION IN THE PERENNIAL GRASS ARISTIDA-STRICTA, Journal of Ecology, 84(5), 1996, pp. 745-754
1 A reciprocal-transplant experiment tested the hypothesis that two po
pulations of a perennial grass were locally adapted. Because populatio
n differentiation might be due to differential adaptation to the prese
nce of surrounding vegetation, plants were transplanted into undisturb
ed areas and areas from which surrounding vegetation had been removed.
As an indirect investigation of the effects of temporal environmental
heterogeneity on the detection of local adaptation, three age-classes
of plants were included in the experiment. 2 Seeds collected from the
two populations were sown into soil from both sites in the greenhouse
. Seedlings of three age-classes were transplanted reciprocally betwee
n the two field sites into both undisturbed quadrats and quadrats from
which vegetation had been removed. Seedling survival was recorded for
six months, and dry weight was determined for all seedlings that surv
ived to the end of this period. 3 Comparisons of seedling survival and
biomass revealed evidence for local adaptation, and the expression of
local adaptation was affected very little by the presence of surround
ing vegetation. Results for vegetation-removal quadrats closely parall
eled those for unmanipulated quadrats. This result does not support th
e hypothesis that the two populations are differentiated with respect
to performance in the presence of vegetation. 4 The detection of local
adaptation depended strongly on the age of transplants. Home-site sur
vival and final biomass advantages were greater for older age-classes.
The effect of transplant age on the detection of population different
iation suggests that evidence of population differentiation may not al
ways be apparent because of temporal variation in environmental condit
ions.