The diagnostic utility of two PCR systems and three PCR detection meth
ods for hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA,vas evaluated in serum samples, A
nested PCR was considered the reference assay and was compared with tw
o single-step PCR methods: the first is based on the detection of PCR
products by liquid hybridization with a P-32-end-labeled probe, and th
e second is the Roche Amplicor colorimetric assay using microwell plat
e hybridization with a specific nucleic acid probe. Using the Pelichec
k HCV RNA Eurohep genotype 1 proficiency panel, our laboratory achieve
d medium-high levels of performance with all three methods. The highes
t sensitivity was, however, observed with the isotopic single-step PCR
(ss-PCR) method. The analytical sensitivity of ss-PCR with isotopic d
etection and ss-PCR with colorimetric detection was identical to that
of nested PCR, with a 100% result concordance. Comparison of ss-PCR wi
th enzyme-linked immunosorbent and RIBA assays in the analysis of clin
ical samples showed a high concordance, ss-PCR methods appear more sui
table for diagnostic application, Nevertheless, HCV RNA PCR cannot be
considered a screening assay; it should be requested in the presence o
f reactive serology or specific clinical symptomatology with altered l
iver parameters, and it is a potential tool for the follow-up of patie
nts with HCV infection.